Saved in this browser. Sign in to sync across devices.
The finding in one sentence: In the studied categories and age groups, approximately 65%–98% of instances in which a psychiatric diagnosis was reported came from only the young person or only the caregiver—not both. This is not the proportion of all teenagers who have a mental-health condition.
What researchers actually did
A research letter published online in JAMA Psychiatry on November 11, 2026 examined 11,868 participants ages 9–17 and their caregivers in the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study. Young people and caregivers answered comparable psychiatric interview questions separately. Researchers compared the diagnosis classifications inferred from each informant's responses across developmental stages.
This was a longitudinal observational analysis, not a randomized study of screening or treatment. The published summary does not establish whether any particular individual report is more accurate, and the classifications from interviews are not a replacement for a full clinical evaluation.
Three findings families can use
PRIVATE EXPERIENCES
Often reported by teens
Young people more often reported depression, sleep problems, substance use, self-harm and suicidal thoughts or behaviors than their caregivers did.
OTHER OBSERVATIONS
Often reported by caregivers
Caregivers more often identified generalized or social anxiety, conduct problems and eating disorders in this cohort.
ACROSS ADOLESCENCE
Agreement remained limited
Concordance generally increased with age but remained low. Differences can represent distinct information, not dishonesty or lack of care.
What the study does not prove: It does not demonstrate that asking both people causes better treatment outcomes, that 65%–98% of all teens have psychiatric conditions, or that caregivers consistently underestimate every concern. Results are cohort-level findings; diagnoses are based on informant-derived interviews and may be affected by recall, disclosure, privacy or assessment differences.
How this applies to autistic teens
The ABCD result is not an autism-specific subgroup treatment finding. Still, its core communication lesson is useful: invite the teen's own account in their preferred format, including AAC, writing, drawing, extra time, concrete language or a private conversation with a qualified clinician. A caregiver may be better positioned to describe changes in routines, sleep, attendance or everyday functioning; the young person may better describe internal distress.
Respect privacy and autonomy. Agree in advance what can be shared with caregivers and how confidentiality limits work, while recognizing that imminent safety concerns require professional help. Do not require teens to disclose intimate thoughts on a public form or to an AI chatbot.
Free family conversation card
Print or use these prompts separately before a visit. They are original conversation aids, not a validated screening questionnaire. If the teen prefers, a clinician can hear their answers privately.
For the young person
- What has been hardest lately, even if others cannot see it?
- How have your mood, sleep, energy, friendships or interests changed?
- Is anything making you feel unsafe, very frightened or hopeless?
- What helps you feel listened to—talking, typing, drawing or a quieter space?
- What is one thing you want to be different in everyday life?
For the caregiver
- What is different from the young person's usual baseline?
- When did changes in sleep, appetite, school, functioning or relationships begin?
- What strengths, interests and communication preferences should the clinician know?
- What supports have been helpful, and which responses have increased distress?
- What questions do you have about safety, assessment, accessibility and follow-up?
Bring both perspectives together
What we both notice: ____________________
What we notice differently: ____________________
What the young person would like help with: ____________________
What we want to ask the clinician: ____________________
Preferred communication and privacy accommodations: ____________________
When to seek additional help
Changes involving suicidal thoughts, self-injury, severe distress, new hallucinations or strongly held beliefs associated with major functional change call for professional assessment. Our autism-and-psychosis guide explains communication approaches and urgent safety distinctions. In the US, call or text 988 for a mental-health crisis; call 911 or go to an emergency department if there is immediate danger or an acute medical emergency.
Prepare for a care appointment → · Organize private care notes, with consent → · Depression support →
Primary study and reporting
- El-Shafie and colleagues. JAMA Psychiatry, research letter published November 11, 2026. DOI: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2026.3768 ↗
- UC San Diego (November 11, 2026), author-institution study summary with cohort numbers and findings ↗
Editorial note: Summary prepared November 12, 2026. Observational evidence; independent clinical review pending. This page is educational, is not a validated screening or diagnostic tool, and does not replace care from qualified professionals.